The news of India’s election as a non-permanent member of the United Nations Security Council was reported with a sense of elation by the national media. Foreign Minister S.M. Krishna referred to it as a “chance to prove worth” for the big throne indicating India’s claim for permanent membership of the Security Council. The South Bloc is also excited about the fact that Pakistan voted in favour of India’s membership. The enthusiasm though comprehensible needs to be tempered.
[Photo Courtesy: The Hindu]
First, Pakistan’s support should not been seen as a purely friendly gesture; it is based on simple diplomatic calculations. Pakistan is expected to bid for Security Council’s non-permanent seat in 2012 and has used this opportunity to ensure that India reciprocates favourably. Garnering international support could prove a more difficult task for Pakistan than it is for India. Moreover, Pakistan’s vote, though heartening, was not critical for India’s election.
Second, securing non-permanent membership has limited salience. The real players in the Council are the five permanent members with the power to veto decisions. Votes of the non-permanent member though not ineffectual, are less critical in determining the Council’s decisions.
Third, non-permanent seat is not a stepping stone to gaining permanent membership on the Council. Overhaul of the Security Council involves more complex and wider manoeuvring than simply India’s claim as an ‘emerging global power.’ If anything, the diplomatic efforts for securing the non-permanent seat could make India realize the difficulty in grabbing the laurels of permanent membership. The support of 187 members for India’s candidature is being widely celebrated in the political and bureaucratic community. But this celebration needs to take cognizance of the fact that India was the only country from Asia to contest for the seat; Kazakhstan had earlier withdrawn its membership. How would India have fared in the face of competition? A crude reminder is the 1996 contest between India and Japan. In 1996 India managed to secure only 40 votes as opposed to Japan’s 142 votes. Moreover since 1992, when India last held the seat, Japan has occupied the position thrice, Pakistan and Indonesia twice.
Winning the non-permanent seat might be an occasion for celebration but it is also an occasion to ponder. It is an occasion to ponder on India’s diplomacy in the United Nations for the next two years. India’s independent stand in the Security Council could displease the United States, especially on the issue of imposing sanctions on Iran. The question is how will India use the current opportunity to demonstrate its credentials for permanent membership of the Security Council? Can India follow the course taken by Turkey and Brazil (non-permanent Security Council members) in June 2010 by voting against imposition of sanctions on Iran?
Security Council, considered inconsequential by many, continues to remain an important arena for diplomatic posturing and comprehending the foreign policy orientations of member states. Non-permanent membership of the Security Council might not be a compelling opportunity to fashion the course of international affairs but is a valuable opportunity to shape global perceptions about India’s capabilities as an emergent power.
A few months ago, I wrote about the early stages of the conflict in Ukraine through the lens of Sun Tzu’s The Art of War. While it appears likely that the war will carry on into the foreseeable future, enough time has passed for us to make an honest assessment of each side’s relative […]
The Ukrainian Army has made dramatic strides in the last few weeks. Ukraine’s tactical commanders have outfoxed their Russian counterparts, and by issuing a feint towards the south the UA has been able to earn substantial gains in the north of their country. The impact of these efforts have been compounded by the steady stream […]
In mid-May the Irish political party, Sinn Féin, won the plurality of seats in the Northern Ireland Assembly. Many American readers might not fully understand the significance of Sinn Féin’s political victory- but rest assured that subjects of the United Kingdom and a wide range of political movements the world over have heard the message […]
The first wave of the Russian offensive in Ukraine has fallen short of Russian autocrat Vladmir Putin’s ambitions. Most analysts deduced that Putin had hoped to achieve a decapitation strike of the Ukrainian government- taking Kiev and replacing Ukrainian President Vladimir Zolinski with a pro-Kremlin voice. Kiev has been threatened repeatedly through the course of […]
On the weekend of March 26th, the notorious MS-13 gang went on a massive killing spree in El Salvador which left more than 70 people dead by Sunday. Even for a country where powerful gangs hold massive sway, this recent tragedy stands out considering that it was the bloodiest day on record since the civil […]
