Law and Security Strategy

See All Press
Legitimacy of Violence
February 23, 2010 6 min. read

A new tradition has emerged in American public discourse.  After a suicide attack occurs on U.S. soil, the public debates whether or not the attack is “terrorism.”  This happened last fall after the Hasan shooting and it’s happening again after the IRS attack.  At Discovery News, Ian O’Neill looks to the dictionary, the FBI’s web-site, […]

Read more
Belated Thoughts on Avatar
February 20, 2010 4 min. read

I saw Avatar last week, just in time, apparently, to truly understand the significance of this: While I understand the the analogy, I also see the differences between James Cameron’s fictional scenario and the actual scenario unfolding in the Middle East.  For me, the most significant distinction is the complete lack of pretexts in Avatar […]

Read more
Great Decisions: R2P
February 18, 2010 5 min. read

Over the weekend, I watched the Great Decisions episode on the responsibility to protect (R2P).  The episode consists of a conversation with Joe Volk (from the Friends Committee on National Legislation) and Monica Serrano (from the Global Centre for the Responsibility to Protect), among other experts, including Ban Ki Moon, who chime in on the […]

Read more
Obama Same As Bush
February 17, 2010 1 min. read

Last year there was Jack Goldsmith’s The Cheney Fallacy. Then, a few months later, came Eric Posner’s article in Foreign Policy. Now comes John Bellinger’s New York Times editorial (h/t to Opinio Juris). These editorials hit the nail on the head.  As Bellinger writes, “the Bush administration demonstrated a greater commitment to international law in […]

Read more
Free Speech and Terrorism
February 16, 2010 2 min. read

In case you missed it, the New York Times had an interesting article last week about the Holder v. New Humanitarian Law Project case.  The case concerns Ralph Fertig, who would like to provide support to the Kudistan Workers’ Party (PKK) to help them peacefully achieve their objectives.  However, Fertig’s endeavor may be illegal, as […]

Read more
More Goldstone Reading
February 12, 2010 1 min. read

In the comments section of yesterday’s Goldstone post, David Bernstein points our way to many critiques of the Goldstone Report he deems valid and substantive.  I recommend reading them and also perusing the spirited debate in the comments section of Bernstein’s Volokh Conspiracy post from yesterday.  Deem for yourself whether the critiques rise to the […]

Read more
Goldstone Report "Nuttiness"
February 11, 2010 2 min. read

David Bernstein of The Volokh Conspiracy examines an interview with Desmond Travers, a member of the fact-finding mission that resulted in the Goldstone report.  Bernstein lists some quotes from the interview, stating: All the quotes check out, but the quotes recounted above don’t begin to illustrate Travers’s hatred of Israel, unwillingness to credit anything Israel […]

Read more
Why Countries Violate The Convention Against Torture
February 5, 2010 1 min. read

Someone I know  at NYU has co-written a paper positing an interesting theory on why some countries sign, ratify, then violate the Convention Against Torture (CAT).  The theory: authoritarian leaders sign and ratify the CAT, then violate it, to show their domestic opponents how committed they are to suppressing opposition.  Read about it at The […]

Read more
Obama and the ICC
February 3, 2010 5 min. read

So it seems the Obama administration has decided not to join the International Criminal Court (ICC), a decision that comes as no surprise.  The news comes from Jurist, which reported last week about a talk given by the U.S. Ambassador-at-large for War Crimes Issues, Stephen Rapp: Speaking at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law, […]

Read more
Miscellaneous Detention Links
February 3, 2010 1 min. read

These all come courtesy of Security Law Brief: A Canadian victim of rendition is appealing to the Supreme Court. Five American terror suspects are alleging that they were subjected to various forms of torture including electric shocks by the FBI and Pakistani police. Latvia will take one of the U.S.’s Guantanamo inmates. Marc Ambinder theorizes […]

Read more
"Legality is a necessary condition for military action. It's not a sufficient condition"
January 29, 2010 4 min. read

So said Lord Goldsmith, the UK’s former Attorney General, yesterday at the UK’s  Iraq inquiry.  In 2003, Goldsmith provided the legal okay for the UK to participate in the Iraq invasion.  You can find notes on Goldsmith’s testimony at TimesOnline here.  Before the invasion, Goldsmith originally believed UN resolution 1441 (downloadable here) did not provide […]

Read more

Popular from Press